“The Muscular Middle” by Chancellor Mike Uram
What Conservative Judaism Stands For, and Why the World Needs It Now
In his first Rabbinical Assembly keynote as JTS Chancellor, Rabbi Mike Uram makes the case for building a “muscular middle”: a fierce, unapologetic approach to Jewish life that embraces complexity and refuses to let differences tear us apart. Drawing on Torah and his years in Jewish leadership, he lays out a new vision for the movement’s future and challenges us to rethink where we spend our energy.

Standing before the Rabbinical Assembly for the first time as Chancellor of Â鶹ԭ´´, I was struck by how many people in the room had shaped me: friends, teachers, and mentors whose wisdom and generosity made me the rabbi I am. I begin with gratitude to them, because nothing I am about to say grows out of my work alone.
Before turning to my main subject, a brief word on the state of JTS. Our classrooms are full. Our students are serious about Torah and serious about Israel. The institution is financially stable. And we are planning, with real ambition, to expand our impact on the Jewish people and on the world. I share this not as a report card but as a foundation: we are in a position to think boldly about the future, and that is exactly what I want to do here.
What Do We Stand For?
For more than twenty years as a rabbi, I worked mostly outside the institutions of the Conservative movement: at Hillel, at Pardes, and at the Jewish Federations of North America. I spent a great deal of time consulting for and partnering with the foundations and organizations that make up the alphabet soup of North American Jewish life. Over those years I heard more than my share of cracks and comments about Conservative Judaism. I suspect you have heard them too. Perhaps, in a weak moment, you have even made a few.
Since arriving at JTS, the question I have heard most often is a version of the same one: What does the Conservative movement actually stand for? What is distinctive about our way of approaching Judaism?
I do not think there are easy answers to that question, and I certainly do not have the hubris to claim I have figured it out after four months as chancellor. What I can offer, I hope, is some new energy and some fresh perspective from someone who has worked both inside and outside the movement. I want to start a conversation: to workshop a set of ideas together, to 1
find hope and common cause, to be inspired about our future, and, frankly, to get our swagger back.
Forty-Nine by Forty-Nine
Let me begin, as we should, with a piece of Torah. It is a text I learned while working at Pardes, where it came to be known simply as “49×49.” The name is meant to be a branded, sticky shorthand for a much more nuanced idea. The midrash teaches:
Rabbi Yannai said: The words of Torah were not given as clear-cut decisions. With every word the Holy One spoke to Moses, God offered forty-nine reasons to declare a thing pure and forty-nine reasons to declare it impure.
Moses said: Master of the Universe, how long must we keep examining before we know the law?
God answered: Follow the majority. If the majority say impure, it is impure; if the majority say pure, it is pure. (Midrash Tehillim 12:4)
This text captures one of the great countercultural ideas in Judaism: we find truth in complexity, not in simplicity. Rather than treating a political or religious question as a binary, the 49×49 asks us to reject the binary, to dig deeper, and to understand that both sides have faces, stories, and lived experiences that shape how they see the issue. The text even uses the word “panim,” faces, for these reasons, reminding us that people are not simply whom they voted for or where they fall on a given issue. Moreover, real life cannot be broken down into simple either/or choices. Real truth is often found in a gam v’gam, both/and approach.
I find enormous beauty in Moses’ response. He reacts exactly the way people react when they are stressed or afraid: “I get it. Complexity. But when will I know the answer?” Anyone who has led a community in recent years knows that feeling. Are we masking for COVID or not? Are we hosting the controversial Israel speaker or canceling the event?
And I love God’s answer. The text and its prooftext are complicated, but the way I have come to teach it, God is saying something like: “Oh, Moshe. It’s sweet that you think, in a world full of imperfect people, imperfect knowledge, and imperfect systems, that you will ever find a perfect answer.”
There is no perfect answer. The best we can do is reject the binary and resist the community’s urge to split into two camps. We can hold people together, keeping them talking and thinking until we find enough common ground to build a workable majority, so that we can move forward together. Rather than picking winners and losers, the midrash points us toward mahloket l’shem shamayim, disagreement for the sake of heaven, practiced in a way that builds a strong center capable of moving forward. Perhaps with some tension, but together nonetheless.
The Muscular Middle
The 49×49 is a useful tool for building healthy culture in families, communities, and organizations struggling through this moment of political divisiveness. But I believe it is also a powerful metaphor for what Conservative Judaism can be. I have come to call it the muscular middle.
I don’t mean “muscular” as in masculine, and I don’t mean it in a physical or literal sense. Honestly, the main reason I like the phrase is the alliteration. I want something simple and sticky that gets all of us thinking and talking about the same thing. So, consider this a working idea, offered for us to workshop together.
Here is the problem it is meant to address. Any movement or idea that does not live at the extremes struggles with being a bit mushy and hard to define. It is far easier for the far right and the far left to be muscular and absolute. Their positions fit neatly on a bumper sticker or an Instagram post. Their ideas are so firm that you can be “canceled” for disagreeing. The extremes are so loud that it often feels as though we have only two choices.
But they do not represent most of us. Research from Jonathan Haidt found that the most hardened partisans on the left and the right together make up only a small fraction of Americans. Yet those black-and-white voices dominate the public square and set the terms of every political issue and news cycle. That leaves the large majority of us unrepresented, and often feeling alone, because we don’t agree with either pole.
To make this concrete: in the way the news, social media, and the algorithms spin it, Israel is either perfect or worse than the Nazis. The same flattening happens on issue after issue. Yet nearly every thoughtful person I know holds a far more nuanced and multifaceted set of views than this kind of bumper-sticker advocacy allows.
So how do we build a more robust set of options for the majority in the middle? We need to find a way for the middle to say more than “I disagree with them, and I disagree with them.” We need to articulate a vision for the world that is every bit as assertive and values-driven as the extremes. That is where the muscular middle lives.
What might that look like? One approach is to assert, without apology, that complexity is the only way to build a good life, to sustain democracy, to learn anything new, to have a living relationship with God, or to repair the world in any meaningful way. More than that: our addiction to simplicity will make our lives less good, less free, less informed, and less spiritual, and our world less just. Simplicity dresses itself up as virtue, but it gets people hurt. It gets people killed. It is dangerous.
Do you see how muscular that could be?
A Test Case: Israel and the University
I am being a little playful, but let me apply this to a real situation. Just before October 7, 2023, news broke that the Palestine Writes Literature Festival would take place on the University of Pennsylvania’s campus. Penn’s then-new president, Liz Magill, made a serious mistake in how she framed the university’s response. She presented it as a false binary: Penn could either protect free speech or protect its Jewish students. That is a dangerous binary, and it was the wrong response.
I want to be fair to President Magill. From everything I heard, she genuinely cared about Penn’s Jewish community; she simply was not prepared or well supported to handle this issue. But imagine if, instead of free speech versus Jewish students, she had framed the moment through the 49×49 and the muscular middle.
A muscular response would have stepped outside the binary entirely. It would have said that this festival fell beneath the level of intellectual discourse that belongs at an Ivy League university. That Penn is training the future leaders of the world, and the simplistic way this event approached one of the most complex conflicts on earth did not meet Penn’s standards, especially because the lineup included people who were neither writers nor Palestinians, but who had a history of explicit antisemitism.
She could then have announced a conference at the same time that brought together writers from the Palestinian territories and from Israel, with a real plan for fostering constructive dialogue among students and faculty. That is what the muscular middle looks like: rejecting the binary and asserting a values-driven alternative.
What Conservative Judaism Stands For
How do we apply this to Conservative Judaism? How do we articulate our own muscular, values-driven positions?
First, we must reject the bumper-sticker judgments about our movement. We’ve all heard them: We’re too traditional; we’re not traditional enough. We’re too serious; we’re not serious enough. We’re too inclusive; we’re not inclusive enough. We’re not Orthodox, and we’re not Reform. We believe in tradition and change.
We have to own, and be proud of, who we are and what we stand for. I know it is hard to define. But I believe the 49×49 is at the heart of it. Here is one attempt to say affirmatively what the muscular middle stands for:
In a world that values simple answers, we believe complexity is the only way to build a meaningful life.
In a world that wants slogans to solve big problems, we believe in slow, small-batch, deep thinking.
In a world that demands immediate moral certainty, we value curiosity and context.
In a world obsessed with the snapshot of the influencer, we prefer a real, three-dimensional understanding of life.
In a world that tells us we are individual consumers, we choose real-life community, personal growth, and working for values that exist beyond ourselves.
In a world of infinite choices, we value limits that actually set us free.
In a world that rewards attention-seeking, we value modesty.
In a world that never stops, 24/7, we value the power of pausing our lives to sanctify time. 5
In a world that says if I am right, you must be wrong, we preserve the minority opinion, because truth is not a zero-sum game.
In a world that argues to win, we argue to learn and to discover deeper truth.
In each of these examples, we add complexity and reject simple binary choices, because that is who we are, it is what we believe, and we know it is the way to build a better life and a better world. The way Conservative Judaism asks us to think, to feel, and to relate to one another is a powerful antidote to many of the greatest challenges our world will face in the next hundred years.
From Philosophy to Practice
I realize this is somewhat philosophical. So how might we apply it, practically, to our work?
- Reject the simple binaries within our own Judaism. The muscular middle is not only a stance toward the outside world; it is a way of treating one another. One Conservative rabbi doesn’t have to be wrong for you to be right. Or, as my kids would say, don’t yuck my yum. One colleague’s rabbinic career might focus on promoting halakhic observance, another’s on encouraging study of traditional texts, another’s on justice or on building community. Each of us builds a model of rabbinic leadership based on our own lived experiences that helps us filter and bring to life different aspects of Jewish tradition. The power of our approach to Judaism is that we value this kind of diversity and believe that there is more than one way to build a brighter Jewish future.
- Build Jews rather than sustain institutions. I would love to see something like a moratorium on debating the policies and ideology of Conservative Judaism. Raise your hands if you believe that any of the following are essential to building a more vibrant and deeper Jewish future: How about Shabbat? How about kashrut? How about Tikkun Olam? How about the power of community? How about the study of Jewish texts? See how much we actually agree on? But by focusing on policy debates, we commit an unforced error. We end up focusing our energy and our brand on what divides us rather than on what unites us. Imagine what we could do if we spent the next 100 years devoting all of our energy to actually building powerful Jewish life. What if we could multiply by a factor of ten the number of times people get involved in a Shabbat dinner, or read a Jewish book or donate to an important cause or find belonging in a Jewish community? There is so much powerful work we could be doing even if we don’t have simple black and white answers for these policy issues. Moreover, we don’t have to wait until we figure it out before we act. This may sound simple, even superficial. But Richard Joel, a deeply serious Jew and a serious intellectual, helped turn Hillel around with a mission statement that was almost silly, and that everyone still remembers: “maximizing the number of Jews doing Jewish with other Jews.” Simple language can carry deep commitments. Let’s keep our eyes on the horizon and on what we hold in common.
- Turn our diversity into strength. John McKnight and John Kretzmann taught a generation of community builders to begin not with what a community lacks but with what it has, mapping its assets rather than cataloging its deficits. Our movement is wonderfully diverse: in practice, in geography, in age, in theology. Too often we treat that diversity as a problem to be managed. It is, in fact, our greatest asset. This means that our approach to Judaism can create more entry points to deep and meaningful Jewish life than any other. Because we don’t censor any aspect of Jewish tradition, and because our rabbis and organizations offer so many different approaches, we have the capacity to engage millions of North American Jews who have not found their home in other places.
- Exercise discipline. Think of what we could accomplish if we could actually exercise strategic and denominational discipline. Rather than relitigating the same debates (What’s the right way to be Conservative? Who is more authentic? What is the one silver bullet that will solve our problems?), what if we refused to “scratch that itch,” even when it feels good? Instead, what if we focused all of our energy and talent on building the Jewish future we want to see?
Conclusion
Which brings me back to where I began. In an age of bumper stickers, Conservative Judaism offers something the world desperately needs: a way of holding complexity with conviction, of disagreeing for the sake of heaven, of staying together when everything pushes us apart. That is not mushiness. It is strength. It is the muscular middle.
The world needs a strong middle. The world needs champions who see complexity and use it to meet the many challenges facing us.
That is who we are. It is time we said so with confidence.
Thank you, all of you, for being here, and for the work you do every day on behalf of the Jewish people. I am so excited about what we can build together: in our synagogues and schools, in our Hillels and agencies, in our classrooms and in our communities.
Let us go forward together, mi’chayil el chayil, from strength to strength.